Communications Network
Vast Empire  -  New Posts  -  Search  -  Statistics  -  Login 
 
ComNet > Stormtrooper Corps > Archived Army Main ComNet > The Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
 
 
 
Author
Topic:  The Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
Angel
ComNet Marshal
 
Angel
 
[VE-ARMY] 2nd Lieutenant
[VE-DJO] Sith Infiltrator
 
Post Number:  2981
Total Posts:  3342
Joined:  Jul 2003
Status:  Offline
  The Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 8, 2009 9:48:20 AM    View the profile of Angel 
Since I went radical and broke out of the box with the Storm Competition, I would really like some feedback from my troopers with their opinions on it

What did you like? Why?
What didn't you like? Why?
What aspects need fixing?
What can improve it?

If you didn't like it at all, "It was crap" is a fair comment.
Platoon Commander - Storm Platoon | Tactical Officer - Army High Council
TO-PC/2LT Angel/Storm/Phoenix/Dragon/Osiris/Stormtrooper Corps/Tadath/Vast Empire
Imperial Network Star Wars Image
----------------------------------------
Darth Phoenix - Dark Lord of the Sith
DLoS/SI Phoenix/DC-04/Lopen/Dark Jedi Order/Vast Empire
[VP:1]


Imperial Network Star Wars Image
[This message has been edited by Angel (edited June 9, 2009 1:35:06 PM)]
Garryll Gates
ComNet Member
 
Garryll Gates
 
[VE-ARMY] Gunnery Sergeant
 
Post Number:  706
Total Posts:  2159
Joined:  Sep 2007
Status:  Offline
  RE: A Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 8, 2009 10:51:52 AM    View the profile of Garryll Gates 
I liked the whole 'Quality over Quantity' concept. Earlier Competitions had dozens of pages of garbage posts that you had to dig through.

The scoring was pretty good, but I think that the applied bonuses for quality should have been a little more influential.
ASL/GSGTGarryll Gates/2SQD/2PLT/1COM/1RGT/1BAT/Tadath/VEA/VE/EW1 [IH][CCA][BC]
Muse rocks.
If these people want to fight me, I'll blow 'em straight to Hell!
AlanRJ
ComNet Expert
 
AlanRJ
 
[VE-ARMY] First Sergeant
 
Post Number:  1661
Total Posts:  1795
Joined:  Aug 2006
Status:  Offline
  RE: A Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 8, 2009 1:08:58 PM    View the profile of AlanRJ 
This is my own personal thoughts regarding the competition.

What did you like? Why?
When I first was told about the quality over quantity I thought that it was going to be a very poor competition.  I have to say that that is the thing which I enjoyed the most and I have to hope that my writing has improved and will remain at an improved level after this competition is over.

Another thing I liked was the fact that the PC gave the SL/ASL choices over what the squad was to achieve next.  It gave the squad more control over how they wanted their story to progress rather than just being told what they had to do.

What didn't you like? Why?
This will be no surprise to Angel but the part I liked the least was when we had to write from the perspective of a supporting squad.  I felt like the competition was continually building on my writing skills but when asked to write from the viewpoint of a different squad it was definitely a new challenge but a very difficult one and one which I found hard to get started, it felt more like work than a fun thing.  I personally felt that after that round was over it was difficult to get back into character and I and feel that my last posts where not as good as earlier ones in the competition.

What aspects need fixing?
I personally would remove the objective where you had to write from a different squad’s viewpoint.  I believe that the skills you learn in writing from the earlier objectives are sometimes lost when you have to write from a different perspective.

What can improve it?
Apart from the removal of that objective, another thing that I can think of for improvement is to provide the SL/ASL more options of storyline as deciding between just two options is limiting.
ASL/1SG AlanRJ/1SQD/2PLT/1COM/1BAT/1RGT/VEA/VE [<3 Luckystar] [ES2] [IH] [BC] [SoH] [EW2] [CoS] [RoM] [ES1] [CCA] [SC] [GC] {RES} {MRT}


Imperial Network Star Wars Image

Paladin Website
http://paladin.stormtroopercorps.com
Tanus Solvona
ComNet Member
 
Tanus Solvona
 
[VE-ARMY] Gunnery Sergeant
[VE-ICS] Pirivateer Captain
 
Post Number:  478
Total Posts:  744
Joined:  Dec 2006
Status:  Offline
  RE: A Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 8, 2009 5:06:40 PM    View the profile of Tanus Solvona 
Personally I liked it. The squad shift gave me a new perspective to write from and let me see the side of the battle from the rank-and-file. I liked the over all feel of it too; you could still be flexible with the characters despite the constraints of a single objective.
Imperial Network Star Wars Image

SL/GSGT/SF Tanus Solvona/2SQD/2PLT/1CMP/1REG/1BAT/Tadath/VEA [EW1][ES1][LM][BC][CoR][LoS][SRP][CDS][SCA]

CA/GSGT Tanus Solvona/ICS/VE

PRVC Tanus Solvona/YZ-775 (m) Iron Victory/Eyesore/The Osk Company

Occupo dies , quod vos have dies. Tamen exspecto vox dies capio , quod vos mos occupo universus saeculorum.
Mai
ComNet Novice
 
Mai
 
[VE-ARMY] Private First Class
 
Post Number:  35
Total Posts:  145
Joined:  Feb 2009
Status:  Offline
  RE: A Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 8, 2009 10:09:03 PM    View the profile of Mai 
Loved it. Much better than the generic 'slap up and spam' platoon comp structure we've been following for a while. The choice of objectives enabled squads to feel as though they were actively participating and able to direct the flow of the story which is important in maintaining interest. Even liked the chance to write from a diff squad perspective as it gave everyone participating the opportunity to experiment with expendable characters.

Kudos to you Angel
Jester Squad//StormPlatoon
TRP/PFC Mai Shyrr/3SQD/2PLT/1COM/1BAT/1REG/Tadath/VEA

Rawr.
[This message has been edited by Mai (edited June 8, 2009 10:17:53 PM)]
Zeshaun
ComNet Member
 
Zeshaun
 
[VE-ARMY] Corporal
[VE-NAVY] Crewman
 
Post Number:  667
Total Posts:  896
Joined:  Oct 2008
Status:  Offline
  RE: The Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions
June 9, 2009 2:13:33 PM    View the profile of Zeshaun 
this new way that you did the competition was way better than any other competition i've been part of, the objective from a different objective was nice, but very difficult to do, although i enjoyed the character development and the fact that i got to die. over all super awesome
TRP/CPL Zeshaun/1SQD/2PLT/COM/REG/BAT//VEA/VE[LoR][ES1][IH]
[CCA][SC]{RES}Imperial Network Star Wars Imagehttp://www.vastempire.com/wiki/index.php?title=Zeshaun
ComNet > Stormtrooper Corps > Archived Army Main ComNet > The Perfect Storm - Comments/Suggestions  |  New Posts    
 

All times are CST. The time now is 7:45:14 PM
Comnet Jump:

Current Online Members - 0  |  Guests - 127  |  Bots - 0
 
< Contact Us - The Vast Empire >
 
Powered by ComNet Version 7.2
Copyright © 1998-2024 The Imperial Network
 
This page was generated in 0.796 seconds.